type
status
date
slug
summary
tags
category
icon
password

WHY THERE IS EMOTIONAL CULTURAL NORMS SCRIPT?

  • In psychology, the general definition of emotion is a psychological system that assesses information relevant to internal or external contexts, determining whether it can satisfy individual motivational needs (Holodynski & Friedlmeier, 2010). The evaluation of external information (Edey et al., 2017), internal cognitive processing (Harada et al., 2019), and functional responses (Nangyeon, 2016) all exhibit cultural variations.
  • However, past research has traditionally considered emotion to possess cross-cultural consistency:
    • In the half-century following Ekman, classic studies utilized top-down theory-driven research paradigms to investigate the socioemotional information conveyed by facial expressions. This research paradigm, influenced by the cultural background of the investigators, reflects researchers' intuitive perceptions and observations shaped by cultural influences.
    • Early research on facial expressions often overlooked the social communicative function of expressions.
    • Complex dynamic information expression patterns accompany the appearance of facial expressions. Questions regarding which action units are activated and the sequence of activation provide crucial information for emotion recognition and classification.
  • Indeed, emotion is a functional physiological response that arises from the cognitive evaluation of specific stimuli, with cultural variations present in the stimuli, evaluative components, and functional roles.
    • notion image
      notion image
      (Matsumoto & Hwang,2012)

THEORYS TO PROVE EMOTIONAL CULTURAL NORMS SCRIPT

Piecing Together Emotion(Parkinson, 2012)

  • An individual's emotions are shaped by a genetic foundation influenced by cultural and societal forces from infancy. From infancy to childhood, caregivers and societal feedback play a role, and into adulthood, there is a continual internalization of social rules and meanings, forming the instantaneous responses of emotions.
  • Specifically, emotions are not solely determined by genetics or a single cultural influence. Rather, they are jointly driven by the internal features of genetic DNA sequences and external cultural and social processes, aligning with the genetic, transmission, and replication mechanisms of natural selection.

Cultural-Historical Formation of Emotion(Boiger & Mesquita,2012)

  • Exploring Vygotsky's theoretical concepts in historical-cultural psychology through the study of emotions, it posits that human psychology is the result of a bio-cultural-environmental relationship, consistently transitioning from the biological to the cultural.
  • This theory introduces the concept of "Emotional Dialogue," highlighting an inevitable intrinsic connection between emotional vocabulary and historical-cultural realities. Individuals from different cultural backgrounds exhibit intra-group consistency in emotions.
  • Innate emotions in children are fundamental, shared across all humans, characterized by standardized facial expressions. In contrast, the expression and understanding of secondary emotions rely on sociocultural learning, necessitating cultural knowledge, cognitive load, emotional exposure through language, and symbolic communication with the social environment.

The cultural construction of emotions(Mesquita, Boiger, & De Leersnyder, 2016)

  • The active construction of emotions by individuals within culture allows them to benefit from culturally normative emotions.
  • Emotions in line with cultural norms contribute to achieving "intersubjective consensus," involving shared cognitive forces directed towards objects, facts, states of affairs, goals, or values. Experiencing culturally normative emotions correlates with higher happiness and lower symptom reports.
  • Culturally normative emotions enable individuals to navigate the intricacies of the social environment in a coordinated manner, explaining why these emotional patterns occur with higher frequency and intensity.

HOW CULTURE CONSTRUCTS EMOTIONAL NORMS SCRIPT

  • At the collective level:
    • One way collectives promote normative emotional states is by emphasizing them in cultural products people engage with, such as storybooks (Ding, He, & Wang, 2021). Individuals also choose products capable of eliciting culturally valued emotions in others.
    • Typical cultural interactions foster emotions aligned with collective intentions. Interactions triggering normative emotions are considered frequent, while those triggering condemnatory emotions are seen as rare. In all cases, normative emotions promote cultural values and goals, while condemnatory emotions contradict collective intentions (Boiger et al., 2013). Parents instill social-value emotions in children, encouraging them to act according to relevant cultural norms and social structures (Rottger-Rossler et al., 2015; 2013).
  • At the individual level:
    • Individuals actively seek situations fostering emotions beneficial for culturally central tasks (Tsai, 2007; Sims et al., 2014), akin to cultivating emotions useful for other types of tasks (Tamir, Mitchell, & Gross, 2008).
    • The situational components contributing to emotional experiences include valence (positive vs. negative), arousal (high vs. low), and interpersonal relationships (mine emotion vs. our emotion).
    • Emotion-related meaning components, encompassing evaluation and action tendencies, reflect diverse ways people interpret events and their motivations for taking action.
    • It remains to be explored whether there are culturally typical patterns in the ways situational and meaning components jointly construct emotional experiences.
notion image

WHAT IS EMOTIONAL CULTURAL NORMS SCRIPT?

AS EMOTIONAL RECOGNITION SCRIPT

This study investigates how cultural background influences emotion recognition, particularly in relation to emotional body language (EBL). The findings reveal that cultural context significantly impacts individuals' ability to recognize and interpret EBL, highlighting the importance of considering cultural nuances in cross-cultural communication.

AS IDEAL AFFECT

This study investigates the impact of cultural shifts on individual values, focusing on changes in ideal affect (IA) and emotional patterns from Traditionality to Modernity in Chinese society. Findings suggest that individuals with modern values exhibit higher arousal in their ideal affect, influencing emotional body language (EBL) recognition, while those with traditional values tend towards lower arousal and neutrality, indicating a correlation between cultural changes and emotional perception.
REFRENCE
Holodynski, M., & Friedlmeier, W. (2010). Significance of expressions for the development of emotions. Emotion Review2(3), 304-305.Edey, R., Yon, D., Cook, J., Dumontheil, I., & Press, C. (2017). Our own action kinematics predict the perceived affective states of others. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance43(7), 1263.
Harada, J. K., Charles, N., Poeppelmeier, K. R., & Rondinelli, J. M. (2019). Heteroanionic materials by design: Progress toward targeted properties. Advanced Materials31(19), 1805295.
Lim, N. (2016). Cultural differences in emotion: differences in emotional arousal level between the East and the West. Integrative medicine research5(2), 105-109.
Matsumoto, D., & Hwang, H. S. (2012). Culture and emotion: The integration of biological and cultural contributions. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology43(1), 91-118.
Parkinson, B. (2012). Piecing together emotion: Sites and time-scales for social construction. Emotion Review4(3), 291-298.
Boiger, M., & Mesquita, B. (2012). The construction of emotion in interactions, relationships, and cultures. Emotion review4(3), 221-229.
Mesquita, B., Boiger, M., & De Leersnyder, J. (2016). The cultural construction of emotions. Current opinion in psychology8, 31-36.
Boiger, M., Mesquita, B., Uchida, Y., & Feldman Barrett, L. (2013). Condoned or condemned: The situational affordance of anger and shame in the United States and Japan. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin39(4), 540-553.
Röttger‐Rössler, B., Scheidecker, G., Funk, L., & Holodynski, M. (2015). Learning (by) feeling: A cross‐cultural comparison of the socialization and development of emotions. Ethos43(2), 187-220.
Röttger-Rössler, B., Scheidecker, G., Jung, S., & Holodynski, M. (2013). Socializing emotions in childhood: A cross-cultural comparison between the Bara in Madagascar and the Minangkabau in Indonesia. Mind, Culture, and Activity20(3), 260-287.
Tsai, J. L. (2007). Ideal affect: Cultural causes and behavioral consequences. Perspectives on Psychological Science2(3), 242-259.
Sims, T., Tsai, J. L., Jiang, D., Wang, Y., Fung, H. H., & Zhang, X. (2015). Wanting to maximize the positive and minimize the negative: implications for mixed affective experience in American and Chinese contexts. Journal of personality and social psychology109(2), 292.
Tamir, M., Mitchell, C., & Gross, J. J. (2008). Hedonic and instrumental motives in anger regulation. Psychological science19(4), 324-328.
CHINESE VERSION

WHY THERE IS EMOTIONAL CULTURAL NORMS SCRIPT?

  • 心理学中对于情绪的普遍定义是,情绪/情感是一套心理系统,对内部或外部与情景相关的信息进行评估,以决定其是否能满足个人动机的需要(Holodynski & Friedlmeier,2010),其中对外部信息的评估(Edey et al., 2017)、内部认知加工过程(Harada et al., 2019)、功能性反应(Nangyeon, 2016)都是具有文化差异性的。
  • 然而以往研究中认为情绪具有跨文化一致性:
    • 在Ekman 之后的半个世纪里,经典研究都使用自上而下理论驱动的研究范式来探测表情传达的社会性信息,这种研究模式本身受到研究者自身文化背景的影响,反映了研究者受文化影响的直觉和观察。
    • 早期有关面部表情的研究往往忽视了表情的社会沟通功能。
    • 面部表情出现时有复杂的动态信息表达模式,被激活的动作单元有哪些?动作单元被激活的顺序如何?对这些问题的探讨都能为情绪识别和分类提供重要的信息。
  • 事实上,情绪是对特定刺激经过认知评价后产生的功能性的生理反应,刺激、评价成分及功能定位均有文化性。

THEORYS TO PROVE EMOTIONAL CULTURAL NORMS SCRIPT

Piecing Together Emotion(Parkinson, 2012)

  • 个体的情绪,从婴儿期会受到由文化和社会力量塑造的遗传基础影响,到幼儿到儿童期,受到护理人员和社会参照反馈的作用,再到成年期,会不断内化社会规则和意义内化,形成情绪的瞬时反应。
  • 具体来说,情绪一定只有基因决定的,也不是不是单一文化的作用,而是依赖遗传的DNA序列的(内部)特征和文化社会过程(外部)所共同驱动的,符合自然选择的遗传、传递和复制机制的。

Cultural-Historical Formation of Emotion(Mesquita,2012)

  • 通过对情绪的研究来阐述维果茨基关于历史文化心理学的理论概念,认为人的心理是生物-文化-环境关系的结果,始终从生物走向文化的;
  • 也是该理论提出了“情绪方言”(Emotional Dialogue) 这一概念,在情绪,用来指代情绪的词语和历史文化现实之间,存在着一种不可避免的内在特征。不同文化背景中的个体会存在情绪的群体内一致性。
  • 儿童的先天情绪是基本的,对所有人类来说都是共同的,由标准化的面部表情组成;而次级情绪(secondary emotions)的表达和理解依赖于社会学习,需要文化知识和认知负荷,需要与语言接触的情感,需要与社会环境进行意义和符号交流。

The cultural construction of emotions(Mesquita, Boiger, & De Leersnyder, 2016)

  • 文化中个人对情绪的主动建构,使得个体能够从文化规范的情绪中受益;
  • 符合文化规范的情绪有助于个人实现“主体间共识”,即“共同针对对象、事实、事务状态、目标或价值观的思想力量”,体验文化规范情绪与较高的幸福感和较低的症状报告有关。
  • 文化规范的情感使人们能够以协调的方式驾驭错综复杂的社会环境,这也是为什么这些情绪(模式)以更高的频率和强度发生的原因。

HOW CULTURE CONSTRUCTS EMOTIONAL NORMS SCRIPT

  • 集体层面:
    • 集体促进规范情绪状态的一种方式是在人们参与的文化产品中强调规范情绪状态;
      • eg. 故事书(Ding, He, & Wang, 2021);
      • 个体也会选择能够在他人身上产生文化价值情感的产品。
    • 文化中的典型互动会促进符合各自集体意向的情绪;
      • 引发文化规范情绪的互动被认为是频繁的,而引发文化谴责情绪的互动则被认为是罕见的。在所有这些情况下,规范性情绪都促进了文化价值观和目标,而谴责性情绪则违背了集体意图(Boiger et al., 2013)
      • 父母向会向儿童灌输社会价值情感,从而鼓励他们的孩子按照相关的文化规范和社会结构行事(Ro¨ ttger-Ro¨ ssler et al., 2015;2013)。
  • 个体层面:
    • 个体寻找培养对文化中心任务有用的情绪的情境(Tsai, 2007; Sims et al., 2014),就像他们培养对手头其他类型的任务有用的情绪(Tamir & Ford, 2009;Tamir, Mitchell, & Gross, 2008)一样;
      • 情境如何提供情绪体验内容成分:
        • 效价:积极 vs 消极
        • 唤醒度:高 vs 低
        • 人际关系:mine emotion vs our emotion
      • 情绪相关的意义成分(即评价和行动倾向)
        • 评估是人们解释事件的不同方式;
        • 行动倾向反映了人们对事件采取行动的动机。
      • 在情境和意义成分共同构建情绪体验的方式中是否存在文化上的典型模式。
Emotional ContagionMY LIFE